The Christmas Spirit: A Sociological Perspective on Seasonal Altruism
December2019 | Edited December 2019
Stock Photo from Wix
There’s no time like Christmas time, especially for capitalist countries.
I recently came across an article published by Pacific Standard discussing “The Chronic Capitalism of Christmas Movies.” The gist of the piece is that Christmas movies all include similar themes, and those themes all perpetuate the myth of the “good capitalist,” or philanthropist, according to the author of the piece, Elizabeth King. If you think about many Christmas classics (e.g., A Christmas Carol, an example used by King) there is typically a privileged character doing a good deed for someone “less fortunate” than them. Whether it’s love, toys, a Peloton, or literal capital, the spirit of Christmas is one of giving—because nothing perpetuates an economic system dependent on exploitation and inequality like giving.
You can read King’s full piece for a more in-depth look at the capitalist narrative perpetuated by Christmas movies, but what I’d like to focus on here is how that narrative drives our social behavior in immensely impactful ways. How many of you volunteered or donated food, clothing, money, or other goods in the last year? How much of those charitable acts took place sometime between November and January? It’s not merely a coincidence that many of us put our philanthropist hats on during the holidays, but it’s also not a natural biological instinct that’s driving this phenomenon. Rather, it’s a social behavior that we’ve learned through socialization from institutions like the media—including Christmas movies.
While giving, volunteering, and donating around the holidays is always necessary and helpful, this trend doesn't come without social consequences. If we connect the dots, as economist Mathias Ekström has, we'll see that the Christmas spirit is actually connected to a shortage of donations and volunteers in the summer months. Ekström's research shows a huge spike in donations in the month of December, with a rapid decline throughout the rest of the year (see the graph from his 2018 paper on seasonal altruism below).
Main Results from Ekström's 2018 Research
Just this past summer (2019), there were numerous examples of volunteer shortages that had food pantries scrambling to feed those in need, including Master's Manna food pantry in Wallingford, Connecticut. Now, we can't simply blame the Christmas spirit and only the Christmas spirit for these shortages. Things like snowbirds leaving Arizona for the summer also contribute to both donation and volunteer shortages in the summer months. There is also the fact that many kids who face food insecurity don't have school breakfast and lunch to feed them during the summer months, making them more reliant on food pantries. But that fact in and of itself is a great reason to nurture your Christmas spirit year round.
If we let narratives in the media—such as those centered around the "good capitalist" that are rampant in Christmas movies—drive our prosocial behavior, there is a good chance our communities will suffer six month later when they're facing those common summer shortages. The good news is, we are humans with agency who can change our behavior despite the social structures that surround us daily. Instead of letting the media socialize us into only giving over a few months of the year, we can be conscious of the fact that people who face food insecurity are facing it year-round and therefore also need support from those who can offer it year-round. With all that said, I'm challenging myself and others to take the seasonal out of seasonal altruism and let your Christmas spirit persist beyond the holidays and well into 2020.